How is the decision-making process of a machine different from a human?

How is the decision-making process of a machine different from a human?

How to Beat Machine Learning at Decision Making

Previous questionHow to train your memory?
Next questionHow can you convince your parents that the Beatniks are not perverts if they have failed to watch the movie "On the Road"?

answers (5)

Answer 1
July, 2021

A person can make a decision intuitively, not based on experience. Or take into account your personal preferences at a given time. And they can depend not only on logic, but also on the weather, health, surroundings, etc.

And the machine has a well-proven algorithm.

Answer 2
July, 2021

Nothing .

The brain is the same "Chinese room" as the operating system of the machine (who is interested in the "Chinese room", and in general all Turing's ideas on this subject, google).

The brain makes decisions in a split second (and sometimes in a few seconds, according to the latest neurophysiological studies) before you realize this decision. And all our subsequent so-called thinking is just adjusting the justification to the already made decision)

There is one more aspect, descriptive. It is possible to understand exactly how a person "makes a decision" only from the description of the person himself. And he is able to describe not the process itself, but his idea of ​​the process. That, as you understand, are different things)

So we only have access to data at the input and data at the output - in the case of a machine, in the case of a person. And what happens inside the "black box" is a random process that is inaccessible to us) In the case of the car, this is precisely the perspective of the Doomsday, described by Cameron in "Terminator 2".

Answer 3
July, 2021

The machine is guided exclusively by logic. Sometimes simple, linear, sometimes it uses sophisticated methods based on complex algorithms and analysis of huge amounts of data. But this is still only logic.

The emotional and moral sphere plays a huge role in human behavior. This is so, even if the person himself does not realize this and does not admit it.

Perhaps someday machines will become so perfect that they will acquire emotions and the ability to be guided by the principles of their own morals. It is very likely that their emotions and their morals will be very different from ours. But this is still a long way off.

Answer 4
July, 2021

Almost nothing.
Because the process of making a decision by a machine is actually a process of making a decision by a person, embedded in an algorithm and implemented in software.
The only difference is that the machine cannot be distracted, replace information with hopes, arithmetically make mistakes, well, etc. But this difference is not such a difference, since sensible citizens are also not distracted and also do not take wishful thinking.

Answer 5
July, 2021

To oversimplify,

  1. The complexity of the algorithm for choosing a solution to the problem.

  2. Approaching this choice.

Different machines make decisions using different algorithms, which may involve different patterns of behavior, but the process will always be the same.

Obtaining a problem -> choosing a behavior pattern -> calculating possible options -> choosing decisions.

And this very calculation is carried out only on the basis of the results of certain mathematical calculations.

A person also has a similar algorithm (of course, people have it much more complicated), but we “estimate »The best option, based on our experience, advice from our closest environment, mood, you name it.

It is for this reason that machines, WHETHER, cannot make balanced and adequate decisions in everyday life, but in specific areas of life, such as chess, people will never be able to get around the car.

Related question

Will the development of the robot's intelligence entail danger? Can he make a strategically correct, but not humane decision, cat. will negatively affect K.-L. sphere of life?

Read more

How does a pilot make a decision in an emergency?

Read more

Can a machine become human, or will it always be just an imitation of humanity?

Read more

Dr. Cassie Kozyrkov, Chief Decision Scientist, Google, \

What is the difference between the process of death of a star and the process of formation of a black hole?

Read more

How does the scale differ from the student? How is a student different from a shkololo?

Read more

Is it true that the aging process of the human body stops in space?

Read more

When do pilots make a go-around decision? (Sharply in front of the lane in clear weather)?

Read more

Were there any cases when signing online petitions really influenced something: it helped to cancel a decision or make a decision at the state level? organs?

Read more

System 1 & System 2: Why Do We Make Irrational Decisions (Cognitive Biases In A Nutshell)

How to make wooden badges in different shapes? (For example, in the form of a cat)?

Read more

What is needed in order to make a "backup" of the human brain?

Read more

How humane is the execution, from the point of view of medicine?

Read more

How is a stripper different from the current Instagram diva?

Read more

The essence of the business is making a profit from the satisfaction and making the life of paying clients easier?

Read more

Game Theory: The Science of Decision-Making

How rational is Twitter's decision to increase the number of characters to 280?

Read more

How is a blog different from a website?

Read more

How is a computer virus different from a computer worm?

Read more

How is information deleted and restored from a computer? How, for example, is deleting to the trash different from formatting?

Read more

How is a switch different from a router?

Read more

The Computer Science of Human Decision Making | Tom Griffiths | TEDxSydney

How is a Trojan different from a worm?

Read more

How do I make it possible to add files to the repository on github from two different computers?

Read more