If war is the engine of progress, is it ultimately more harmful or beneficial?

If war is the engine of progress, is it ultimately more harmful or beneficial?

All 4 Siege Machines Explained - Basic to Advanced Tutorial (Clash of Clans)

Previous questionOn which website can you thoroughly read or see how the car works? With all the subtleties, with an analysis of everything to the smallest detail
Next questionWill the development of electromagnetic weapons lead to the emergence of new battleships?

answers (3)

Answer 1
August, 2021

Is war the engine of progress? Did you mean Marx's words that the class struggle is the engine of the economy? Or maybe war is the engine of progress for the United States?

War has never been good for the people, but good for the government. For his enrichment of its territory, capital. So it depends on which side you look at.

Answer 2
August, 2021

Sorg and Father Vito Cornelius are talking:

  • The life you serve is born of destruction and chaos. Take, say, a glass - here it is, graceful, frozen, boring. Break the glass.

The glass is broken. Cleaning robots appear.

  • So what? Everything started spinning - the machines are working, eager to prove their usefulness. A whole ballet: colorful and so funny, and now we are creating tribute to the creators, designers, engineers who can feed the kids today, then have their own babies and so on and so on. And the thread of life is not torn. So, Father, constantly destroying, I contribute to the flourishing of life. And we are doing one thing. For you! - drinks cider with cherries.

Chokes and suffocates.

  • Where is the robot that will slap on the back? Or an engineer? Or his children? You see: your so-called power is worth little. Your empire of destruction and darkness is crumbling over one tiny ... cherry. - knocks on the back and saves you from death.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v= KmrJTZkg3rU

Answer 3
August, 2021

The statement that war is the engine of progress is, of course, beautiful, but most likely does not correspond to reality. The reason for the appearance of such a thesis is probably in the visibility and rapidity of changes in a number of areas of science that occur / can occur during the war. This does not take into account the colossal losses in all areas, from the demographic situation to the economic situation of the country.

Yes, the experiments of Nazi scientists gave a lot to medicine, but the price was hardly commensurate (for either side of the conflict). In peacetime, the same research is carried out more slowly, but at much lower costs.

Related question

Is war the engine of progress?

Read more

That the engine of progress - laziness or money?

Read more

If we talk about robotization and the development of artificial intelligence, then what is more important "progress for humans" or "humans for progress"?

Read more

IISS Strategic Dossier launch: Russia’s Military Modernisation: An Assessment

What is more harmful, vape or cigarettes?

Read more

Simplification of the Language - Degradation or Progress?

Read more

Is it harmful to put the engine tuning chip? And what can be the consequences in the future when operating a car if there is chip tuning?

Read more

Why have centuries of science and progress passed, but all the same problems remained - wars, malnutrition, a bunch of diseases, work from 9 to 18?

Read more

What is more harmful: snus or regular cigarettes?

Read more

Biggest challenge in making ML work in the real world with Richard Socher

Technological progress is moving forward, but society as a whole is not developing - people still think about wars, money, etc. Why?

Read more

Is it progress or regression in relation to man, the development of technology in the world? (Will the person get lazy from too comfortable conditions)?

Read more

Is it worth protecting the child from the harmful influence of the network (vulgar language, porn, aggression - if so, how to do it?), Or give him complete freedom?

Read more

While taxiing, is the aircraft driven by the engines on the landing gear or by the thrust of the main engines?

Read more

Is it true that frequent switching on / off of the laptop harms it more than extended periods of time in the on state?

Read more

How many times a WEEK should you train? Calisthenics

If we consider the entire set of digital information, which is more: 0 or 1?

Read more

Is the release of the next iPhone a technical progress?

Read more

What training courses should you refresh your memory for a more specific coverage of the profession if you are a future engineer at a nuclear power plant? And in general for engineering specialties?

Read more

Is it possible to escape during a helicopter flight if the engine fails?

Read more

Is it true that the production of electric vehicles (materials for them) emitted more harmful substances than the production of cars?

Read more

How Did We Get So Rich?

Why is there such a progression pattern in the volume of information carriers? 1GB - 2GB - 4GB - 8GB. Is this some kind of rule or just a convention?

Read more

Which TV channel would be more harmful to the authorities "Dozhd" or "Constantinople"?

Read more