Why are so many so tolerant of the so-called. "pirate parties"? There is no "party of thieves" or "party of rapists".?

Previous questionWhat runet bloggers do you know who have moved to another country and are filming this video?
Next questionHow to make money with reposts and likes?

answers (3)

Answer 1
August, 2021

The parallel with the "party of thieves" or "party of rapists" is not entirely accurate, because a thief and a rapist can rob and rape anyone, and this is not attractive to the majority.

But the idea of ​​selectively infringing on a group of people and redistributing their property in their favor is close to many. The leader of the Pirate Party of Iceland directly says that we are, they say, Robin Hoods, who rob the rich and give out to others, quote: "We want our reputation to be more like Robin Hood and a band of pirates. We propose taking money and power from the rich and giving it to the people "(https://www.newscientist.com/article/2111618-pirate-party-we-want-our-reputation-to-be-more-like-robin-hood/).

For pirate parties, this is expressed not only in the idea of ​​eliminating private ownership of the results of intellectual labor - the same Icelanders, for example, propose to nationalize natural resources. Well, there are many other populist ideas out there like direct e-democracy. I agree with some of them myself.

Answer 2
August, 2021

"Pirates" stand for freedom of the Internet, against the possibility of arbitrarily reducing the traffic of some sites in favor of others, etc. I hope you are in solidarity with them. As for the current system of copyright for texts, music and video, it does not correspond to the current state of technology (inhibits its development and application) and the interests of a growing number of voters. The latter, sooner or later, will lead to a change in legislation (quite possibly, by the votes of the "supported" representatives of ordinary parties, and not the "pirates" themselves), despite the "copyright" lobby. Apparently, inadequate laws are massively violated even in the most law-abiding countries. So what is the point of criminalizing millions of people for the sake of the profits of thousands (mostly not even the authors themselves)? By the way, libraries and educational institutions in Germany already have the right to copy scientific literature from their collections without any payment to publishers. And what is more moral than electronic books from "pirated" libraries?

And the practice of "protecting" digital media from copying using DRM, etc. is absolutely outrageous. According to the law in Germany, for example, the owner of legal content has the right to make one free copy (as a reserve in case of loss or to use on another gadget). And such "protection" puts the purchaser of digital media in a worse position than the purchaser of a paper book.

UPD. By the way, many YouTube videos available in the rest of the world cannot be watched in Germany without an anonymous foreign proxy, etc. We are talking about works legally posted for free by the copyright owners themselves (for example, "Gangnam Style", which once set a record of views). The reason - "copyright protection" by GEMA - one of the German monopoly copyright organizations around the state. GEMA wants to receive money from YouTube for these videos (let me remind you, legally posted by the authors themselves!), YouTube, of course, does not pay, but blocks the ability to view from Germany, not wanting to spend money on courts.

UPD2. Or here's more about GEMA. We have to adopt special laws to "allow" kindergartens and schools to arrange a free concert of children in front of their parents, etc. using "protected" music and songs (GEMA demanded money from them for public performance), non-profit wedding organizers (newlyweds and their relatives) - play music through a tape recorder, etc. (also public performance). And for weddings you need to look at the number and composition of guests: the permission is not absolute. This is all, is it normal? Such "protection" into the furnace. Any free, non-commercial use of legally purchased content should be allowed by default, and only prohibited in some specific cases.

Answer 3
August, 2021

Because rape and piracy are totally different things. Piracy is not even a theft in the original sense of the word, because it does not deprive the owner of any property.

Related question

Let's say my house is being robbed by armed thieves, and there is no money on the phone. How to call the police if the balance is negative?

Read more

What is the peculiarity of B.Yu. Alexandrov and why are there so many memes about them?

Read more

Why are there so many "why" in the world?

Read more

How is snot formed? Why are there so many?

Read more

Why are there so many ads on the Internet?

Almost every article advertises something or encourages to buy, sponsors must be indicated. Previously, this was not, and lived somehow.

Read more

Why are there so many Jews among the Russian elite?

Read more

Why are there so many schoolchildren on the Internet?

they are everywhere, go where they don't need to, rage in the comments, if something doesn't suit them, then you are nobody, because the student is right because he is right.

Read more

Why are there so many sellers of all kinds of equipment on Gorbushka, how is it historically?

Read more

Why are there so many memes about Evgeny Ponasenkov?

Read more

Why are there so many stupid people in Odnoklassniki?

Read more

Why are there so many more men among programmers?

Read more

Why are there so-called "death groups" VK? Who needs it and why?

Read more

Why are there so many rallies in France?

Read more

Why are there so many perverts in chat, video roulettes?

Read more

Why are there so many jokes about IKEA?

Read more

Why are there so many jingoistic patriots on Pikaba?

Read more

Why are there so many jerks on video chat?

Read more

Why are there so many advertisements in VKontakte? ?

Read more

Why is Xiaomi considered a crap phone and there are so many memes about their owners?

Read more

What is Spersy and why are there so many memes with it?

Read more