Why has Esperanto not caught on in international society?

Why has Esperanto not caught on in international society?

Esperanto: One of the World's Best Underutilized Ideas and Its Contributions to World Culture

Previous questionAre there normal guys on dating sites, or just perverts and those looking for "one night stand"?
Next questionHow to launch your own online publication and get people to work without having money?

answers (3)

Answer 1
May, 2021

For the same reason the world still uses the QWERTY layout, although more efficient ones have long been created. The masses are always inert, changes are created by small groups of initiators, followed by the masses (or not).

Strictly speaking, Esperanto has taken root very well. Esperantists live all over the world and actively use Esperanto for everyday communication, travel, business, romantic relationships, etc. Yes, he did not become dominant, like English, but that could not happen. Hitler defeated the Esperanto community in Europe, Stalin in the USSR, and after World War II the rise of the United States began, and with it the victorious march of the English language, which was so marginal. Esperanto was of no interest to anyone politically, and without it it would be naive to expect support from politicians.

Answer 2
May, 2021

Esperanto did not take root because there is no economic, political or military power behind it. Dot. Everything else is from the evil one. And the language itself is great. According to the famous polyglot Benny Lewis, even if not a single person spoke Esperanto, this language would still be worth learning. Firstly, no ethnic language brings brains in such order as Esperanto (well, perhaps, Quechua and Aymara). Ethnic languages ​​teach first of all to cram, and Esperanto teaches to think first. And secondly, Esperanto is an excellent propaedeutic. Numerous experiments in different countries have proved that knowledge of this language greatly facilitates the study of foreign languages. For example, as a result of teaching Esperanto in Hungarian schools, it was found that for Hungarians, knowledge of Esperanto facilitates learning French by 50%, English by 40%, German by 30%, and Russian by 25%.

Answer 3
May, 2021

Why do you need it if you have English? By the time it appeared, English was already widespread, French for example, with which it could hardly compete. The entire civilized world has long been speaking English, but there will be no sense in uncivilized Esperanto. After all, knowing Esperanto, even in the most optimistic scenario, cannot replace knowledge of English. Even if the whole world decides to switch to Esperanto in international communications, English and American scientists and businessmen among themselves will still continue to communicate in their native language. And anyone who wants to study at Harvard and Oxford, trade stocks in London and New York, or even just read scientific articles in magazines like the American Journal of Something, without fluency in English will still be nowhere (just like now nowhere without knowledge of French in the former colonies, where ties with France are strong, and knowledge of Spanish in Latin (South) America).

And it is not so simple. The grammar is regular and simple, everyone learns very quickly, but even with a powerful word-formation system, almost all vocabulary will have to be crammed as hard as in other languages. If you speak a couple of European languages, then you can learn Esperanto without any problems, but the question is - do you need it in this case?

Related question

How to ride in transport without a ticket and not get caught by controllers?

Read more

How has your opinion about society and people changed after reading their answers on this and similar sites?

Read more

Is it true that there has long been an alternative to the internal combustion engine, but oil companies do not allow these technologies to be developed?

Read more

The language that never was: Esperanto fans gather in celebratio

How to Increase Internal Memory in MacBook Air 11 '' Mid 2012 (128 GB is not enough) and install the system on a new drive?

Read more

Are Pokémon caught in Donbass?

Read more

Why does the "intellectual" Sberbank freeze online, it takes several hours to enter and transfer funds during the day, charges a commission on internal bank transfers throughout the country, and has a different policy abroad?

Read more

Why in the fall, when the heating season has not yet begun, is it still warm in the house (+7 on the street, at 18)?

Read more

Why in the twenty-first century, even in theory, has not an alternative to a wheelchair been invented that would easily climb stairs and so on?

Read more

A universal language exists, so why don't we all speak it?

Everyone has things that, for various reasons, do not want to share on social networks. What would you not write about on Facebook and why?

Read more

After the recent information attack (events related to Kemerovo) on our society, would it not be advisable to impose restrictions on the use of the Internet?

Read more

Who buys pirated discs in 2019? And why has this business still not gone bankrupt?

Read more

How has a society of simple stonemasons been able to attract the most influential people to its organization?

Read more

Why has it become fashionable on the Internet to express one's emotions through "ahahahah", and not the usual "hahaha"?

Read more

Socialists Should Learn Esperanto!

Several times I have already caught myself on ideas that no one has yet implemented, but they could be suitable for large IT giants. How can you use it?

Read more

How not to lose yourself in yourself? In a society of people I lose all my thoughts, attitudes and desires, becoming confused and empty

Read more

Why has Pascal not achieved the popularity of C ++?

Read more

The APPLE corporation is often mentioned in the media. Why has Google and Android not received such attention?

Read more

Why on television in programs songs are not performed live?

Read more

The Transformative Vision of Esperanto | Esther Schor | TEDxRoma

What are the meaning, goals and objectives of the teaching profession in the modern information society in which any student can receive information on the Internet?

Read more

If communism is a stage in the natural evolution of society, then why is a violent revolution needed?

Read more